Understanding the Link Between Chronic Dieting and Disordered Eating: Insights from an Eating Disorder Therapist
As an eating disorder therapist, I've had the privilege of supporting people navigate the complexities of disordered eating and diet culture. One common thread I've observed among many of my clients is the pervasive influence of chronic dieting on their relationship with food, body image, and overall well-being.
The relationship between chronic dieting and the development of eating disorders is complex and multifaceted, and the prevalence of eating disorders among chronic dieters can vary depending on various factors such as:
individual susceptibility
genetic predisposition
environmental influences
psychological factors
While chronic dieting can increase the risk of developing disordered eating patterns, not all chronic dieters will go on to develop clinically significant eating disorders.
Understanding chronic dieting and its impact
Research suggests that a substantial proportion of individuals with eating disorders report a history of chronic dieting or weight control behaviors preceding the onset of their disorder. For example, restrictive dieting, excessive exercise, and preoccupation with weight and food are commonly observed behaviors among individuals with anorexia nervosa, bulimia nervosa, and binge eating disorder. In fact, the fear of weight gain, feeling like one is overeating, feelings of guilt, thinking about dieting, and a desire for thinness are all predictive of eating disorder severity (Levinson, C.A., et al., 2022). These same factors are a large part of the diet mentality.
The National Eating Disorders Association found that 35% of dieting becomes obsessive, and 20 to 25% of those diets turn into eating disorders. It's important to note that chronic dieting can serve as a significant risk factor for the development of eating disorders, particularly when coupled with other predisposing factors such as low self-esteem, body dissatisfaction, perfectionism, trauma, and genetic vulnerability. Additionally, the pervasive influence of diet culture and societal pressure to attain unrealistic body ideals can further exacerbate the risk of developing disordered eating patterns among chronic dieters.
What does chronic dieting lead to?
Chronic dieting, often characterized by cycles of restrictive eating, calorie counting, and obsessive food monitoring, can have profound consequences on both physical and psychological health. While the initial intention behind dieting may be to achieve weight loss or improve health, the restrictive nature of dieting can trigger a cascade of detrimental effects such as:
Disrupted Hunger and Fullness Cues:
Chronic dieting disrupts the body's natural hunger and fullness cues, leading to a loss of trust in one's internal signals of hunger and satiety. This can result in cycles of overeating and under-eating, as individuals struggle to regulate their food intake in response to genuine physiological cues.
Increased Preoccupation with Food:
Constantly monitoring food intake, counting calories, and adhering to strict dietary rules can fuel an obsession with food and eating. Thoughts about food may consume a significant amount of mental energy, leaving individuals feeling preoccupied and anxious about their next meal or snack.
Negative Body Image:
Chronic dieting often perpetuates a cycle of body dissatisfaction, as individuals internalize societal ideals of thinness and equate their self-worth with their appearance. Despite efforts to achieve weight loss through dieting, many individuals find themselves feeling increasingly critical of their bodies. This leads to feelings of shame, guilt, and low self-esteem.
Emotional Distress:
The relentless pursuit of weight loss through chronic dieting can take a toll on individuals' emotional well-being, contributing to feelings of frustration, depression, and anxiety. The fear of gaining weight or deviating from strict dietary rules can trigger intense emotional distress, further perpetuating disordered eating behaviors.
What are the long-term effects of chronic dieting?
While chronic dieting may initially promise short-term weight loss or improvements in health, the long-term effects can be far more detrimental:
Development of Disordered Eating Patterns:
Chronic dieting often sets the stage for the development of disordered eating patterns, such as binge eating, emotional eating, or orthorexia (an obsession with healthy eating). The rigid rules and restrictions imposed by diets can lead to a loss of control around food and a heightened vulnerability to developing clinically significant eating disorders.
Physical Impacts:
Dieting can have damaging impacts on physical health, including an increased risk of heart disease, gallstone formation, constipation, exhaustion and energy loss, hair loss, loss of bone strength and density, and low immunity to illness when the body is lacking adequate nutrition and calories. In addition, yo-yo dieting (losing weight and gaining it over and over again) can cause long-term metabolic disruptions, loss of muscle, stress on the heart and kidneys, and an increased risk for non-alcoholic fatty liver disease.
Metabolic Adaptations:
Prolonged calorie restriction and weight cycling associated with chronic dieting can disrupt metabolic functioning, making it increasingly difficult for the body to maintain weight loss over time. This phenomenon, known as metabolic adaptation, can contribute to weight regain and further perpetuate the cycle of chronic dieting and weight cycling.
Nutritional Deficiencies:
Chronic dieting often results in inadequate nutrient intake, as individuals may eliminate entire food groups or severely restrict their calorie intake in pursuit of weight loss. Over time, this can lead to nutritional deficiencies, compromised immune function, and increased susceptibility to health problems such as osteoporosis, anemia, and cardiovascular disease.
Impaired Psychological Well-Being:
The relentless pursuit of weight loss through chronic dieting takes a toll on individuals' psychological well-being, contributing to increased levels of stress, anxiety, and depression. The constant focus on food, weight, and body image can erode self-esteem, strain interpersonal relationships, and diminish overall quality of life.
Final thoughts as a North Carolina eating disorder therapist
As an eating disorder therapist, I've witnessed firsthand the detrimental impact of chronic dieting on individuals' lives. While diet culture perpetuates the myth that thinness equals health and happiness, the reality is far more complex. Chronic dieting not only fails to deliver sustainable weight loss but also puts individuals at risk for developing disordered eating patterns, metabolic disturbances, and psychological distress.
It's crucial for all of us to recognize the limitations of dieting and instead focus on cultivating a balanced and compassionate approach to health and well-being. If you or someone you know is struggling with chronic dieting or disordered eating, know that you're not alone, and help is available. I'm here to offer support, guidance, and compassion on your journey towards healing and recovery. Together, we can challenge harmful dieting beliefs, cultivate a healthier relationship with food and body, and embrace a more authentic and fulfilling way of living. Contact me if you’re ready to ditch diets for good!
Getting started with eating disorder therapy in Raleigh, NC
Empower yourself with support by reaching out to Counselor Kate. My eating disorder therapy services are designed to provide compassionate guidance and personalized treatment options tailored to your needs. Take the first step towards healing and reclaim control over your well-being by following the steps below:
Schedule a consultation here so I can get to know you better.
Learn more about who I am.
Begin online eating disorder therapy or see me in person!
Other services I offer in North Carolina:
My goal is to provide compassionate support to help individuals process and release trauma stored in the body with trauma and somatic therapy. Rediscover a harmonious relationship with food and your body through my intuitive eating services!